
Still Paying PMI? What to Check Before You Refinance
By Dr. Angela Andrews, PhD, REALTOR®/Broker, SRES®, ABR® | Dr. Downsizer™ | Listing Leaders Real Estate
If private mortgage insurance is still on your monthly statement, call your mortgage servicer before shopping for a refinance. On many conventional mortgages, you can ask to cancel PMI once you reach a specific balance and meet the other requirements. That lets you check whether you can remove the charge while keeping the loan you already have.
Maybe you’re weighing whether to stay in your Northwest Indiana home a few more years or move somewhere easier to maintain. Either way, it helps to know what it actually costs to stay. Start with one line on your mortgage statement and one phone call.
Find out what you’re paying for
Pull out your latest mortgage statement and look for a mortgage insurance charge. If the description is unclear, ask the company that collects your mortgage payments to identify it. Ask whether it’s borrower-paid private mortgage insurance on a conventional loan. FHA mortgage insurance and lender-paid mortgage insurance follow different rules, so confirm your loan type before using the numbers below.
Next, find the PMI disclosure from closing. If you can’t find it, ask the servicer for a copy and for the original property value it uses to calculate your cancellation date. For a purchase, that’s generally the lower of the contract price or the appraisal at the time. If you refinanced, it’s generally the appraisal from that refinance.
Know which number lets you ask and which date matters
For many covered conventional loans, these are the milestones to check:
80% of original value: You can ask. You can generally submit a written cancellation request when your balance is scheduled to reach 80%, or sooner if extra principal payments bring it there. The servicer can require a good payment history, current payments, confirmation that there’s no second lien, and evidence that the property hasn’t declined in value.
78% of original value: Check the scheduled date. PMI generally ends automatically when your balance is scheduled to reach 78%, provided you’re current. An extra payment can move up the date you’re eligible to request cancellation, but it doesn’t move up this automatic termination date.
Halfway through the loan term: Check the backstop. If PMI hasn’t already ended, federal law generally requires it to end by the first day of the month after the midpoint of the amortization schedule, provided you’re current.
Say you bought for $260,000 and the home appraised for $250,000 at closing. In this example, you’d use $250,000 as the original value. The 80% request threshold would be $200,000, and the 78% threshold would be $195,000. Ask the servicer for both dates so you can see whether making a request could save you any payments.
If your home is worth more today, ask before ordering an appraisal
Some loans have a separate way to request cancellation based on the home’s current value. Fannie Mae’s servicing guide, for example, lists requirements that can vary based on how long you’ve had the loan, how much you owe relative to the property’s value, and whether you’ve made substantial improvements. Ask whether your loan qualifies and how the servicer wants the value documented before paying for an appraisal.
Take these questions into the call
1. What kind of mortgage insurance do I have, and what am I paying for it each month?
2. What original value and principal balance are you using?
3. What are my earliest request date and scheduled automatic termination date?
4. Can I qualify using today’s value? What documentation or valuation fee would apply?
5. Where do I send a written request, and how will you confirm when the charge ends?
Ask for the answers in writing. If you’re thinking about selling soon, compare any valuation fee with the PMI payments you might avoid before your expected move. If the automatic termination date is close, you may decide the paperwork and fee aren’t worth it. Use the payment you’re actually making in your budget until the servicer confirms the change.
If this is part of a bigger stay-or-move decision, my Choose Your Next Home guide can help you compare the full cost of your options. If you’d like to talk through what staying or moving could look like in Lake or Porter County, let’s talk. You don’t need to be ready to list.
Dr. Downsizer™ — A Transition. Not a Transaction.
Sources: Consumer Financial Protection Bureau: When can I remove PMI? and 12 U.S.C. § 4902: Termination of private mortgage insurance.



Comments