
What Do I Do With Old Paint? A Cleanout Guide for Lake and Porter Counties
By Dr. Angela Andrews, PhD, REALTOR®/Broker, SRES®, ABR® | Dr. Downsizer™ | Listing Leaders Real Estate
“I’m clearing out the garage before a move. Where can I take the old paint?”
Start with the label. In Lake and Porter counties, usable latex paint may qualify for recycling at Hobart City Barns. Oil-based paint goes through your own county’s household hazardous waste program. If the label is missing or the can is leaking, call for instructions before you move it.
There’s usually a shelf in the garage that holds three shades of beige and a can no one remembers buying. It’s easy to leave that shelf until the rest of the house is packed. I’d put it near the top of your cleanout list, especially if you’re getting ready to sell. You may need two different disposal plans, and one of them depends on the collection calendar.
Read the cans before you load the car
Look for words such as latex, acrylic, or water-based on the paint label. Instructions to clean brushes with soap and water are another clue. If the label says oil-based, make a separate note. Put stains, varnishes, and cans with unreadable labels on your “call and ask” list. Hobart’s latex program excludes stains of every type.
Keep products in their original labeled containers. Don’t combine half cans to save room, even if they look like the same color. If a container is leaking or badly corroded, leave it undisturbed and ask your local waste district how to handle it before trying to transport it. Don’t pour leftover paint down a drain or storm sewer.
Latex paint: Check the Hobart drop-off rules
Hobart City Barns, at 340 S. Shelby St. in Hobart, accepts qualifying latex paint from both Lake and Porter County residents, with ID. The city excludes paint older than five years, paint that has frozen or been mixed with other material, and cans that are rusted or leaking. Confirm hours and eligibility at 219-942-6121 before loading your vehicle.
What about that can of bedroom paint from two remodels ago? If it’s clearly identified as latex and doesn’t qualify for recycling, check your Lake County latex guidance or Porter County latex guidance, then confirm pickup instructions with your trash provider. Ask whether it accepts completely dried latex paint and how it wants the can and lid set out. Use this option only for paint you’ve confirmed is latex.
Oil-based paint: Use the program for the home’s county
Lake County: The Lake County Solid Waste Management District lists oil-based paint as accepted at its household hazardous waste events for Lake County residents. As of November 7, 2026, the district says its 2026 program has ended. If you need to clear the home before the next collection, contact the district for instructions and check its page for the 2027 schedule.
Porter County: Porter County Recycling lists oil-based paint for its household hazardous waste events and says there is no permanent county drop-off for those materials. Check the district’s current calendar or call for guidance if your cleanout can’t wait.
If you’re helping a parent move, check which program serves their address before offering to take the cans. Hobart’s shared latex program and the county hazardous waste collections have different residency rules.
Decide which touch-up paint is worth offering the buyer
If you’re selling, set aside only the usable cans you can confidently match to a current room or surface. Add a note with the room, color, and finish if you know them. Ask through your real estate agent whether the buyer wants those specific cans, and make a plan to remove the rest before you hand over the keys.
You don’t have to clean the whole garage this afternoon. Take photos of the readable labels, make one list, and put the first call on your calendar. That’s enough to turn a shelf you’ve been avoiding into a task you know how to finish.
For more local help, visit my Lake County resources or Porter County resources. If you’re sorting out what to tackle before selling a longtime home, let’s talk about a plan that fits your timing.
Dr. Downsizer™ — A Transition. Not a Transaction.
Additional safety guidance: U.S. EPA household hazardous waste and Indiana Department of Environmental Management.



Comments